A data-model comparative study of ionospheric positive storm phase in the midlatitude F region

G. Lu, L. P. Goncharenko, A. J. Coster, A. D. Richmond, R. G. Roble, N. Aponte, L. J. Paxton

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

A strong positive storm phase was observed by both the Millstone Hill and Arecibo incoherent scatter radars during a moderate geomagnetic storm on 10 September 2005. The positive storm phase featured an interesting UT–altitude profile of the F region electron density enhancement that closely resembles the Greek letter L. The radar measurements showed that the uplift of the electron density peak height corresponded to a strong upward ion drift, whereas the subsequent falling of the peak height coincided with a downward ion drift. Using realistic, time-dependent ionospheric convection and auroral precipitation as input, the thermosphere–ionosphere electrodynamics general circulation model (TIEGCM) is able to reproduce the same L-like structure in the electron density profile, along with many large-scale features in electron temperature and vertical ion drift as observed by the radars. Over the 3-day period of 8–10 September, our simulation results show an error of 1%–4% for hmF2, electron, and ion temperatures at both radar locations. The estimated error for NmF2 is about 9% at Millstone Hill and 19% at Arecibo. However, the simulated vertical ion drifts are less accurate, with the normalized root-mean-square errors of 72% at Millstone Hill and 52% at Arecibo, due largely to model’s inability to capture the large temporal fluctuations measured by the radars. However, it reproduces reasonably well the overall large-scale variations during the 3-day period, including the storm-time-enhanced upward ion drift that is responsible for the interesting F region density profile. The model is also able to reproduce the temporal and spatial total electron content variations as shown in the global GPS maps. The comparison with the GUVI O/N2 is less satisfactory, although there is a general agreement in terms of relative O/N2 changes during the storm in the longitudinal sector between 60°W and 80°W where the radars are located. The detailed data–model comparison carried out in this study is helpful not only to validate the model but also to interpret the complex observations. The TIEGCM simulations reveal that it is the enhanced meridional neutral wind, not the penetration electric field, that is the primary cause of the L structure of the F region electron density profile.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationMidlatitude Ionospheric Dynamics and Disturbances. 2008
EditorsAnthea J. Coster, Tim Fuller-Rowell, Michael Mendillo, Roderick Heelis, Paul M. Kintner, Anthony J. Mannucci
PublisherBlackwell Publishing Ltd.
Pages63-75
Number of pages13
ISBN (Electronic)9781118666555
ISBN (Print)9780875904467
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 1 2008

Publication series

NameGeophysical Monograph Series
Volume181
ISSN (Print)0065-8448
ISSN (Electronic)2328-8779

Fingerprint

temperate regions
F region
ionospherics
comparative study
electron density
ion
electron density profiles
ions
electrodynamics
general circulation model
electron energy
radar measurement
radar
root-mean-square errors
magnetic storms
electron
ion temperature
profiles
falling
geomagnetic storm

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Geophysics

Cite this

Lu, G., Goncharenko, L. P., Coster, A. J., Richmond, A. D., Roble, R. G., Aponte, N., & Paxton, L. J. (2008). A data-model comparative study of ionospheric positive storm phase in the midlatitude F region. In A. J. Coster, T. Fuller-Rowell, M. Mendillo, R. Heelis, P. M. Kintner, & A. J. Mannucci (Eds.), Midlatitude Ionospheric Dynamics and Disturbances. 2008 (pp. 63-75). (Geophysical Monograph Series; Vol. 181). Blackwell Publishing Ltd.. https://doi.org/10.1029/181GM07

A data-model comparative study of ionospheric positive storm phase in the midlatitude F region. / Lu, G.; Goncharenko, L. P.; Coster, A. J.; Richmond, A. D.; Roble, R. G.; Aponte, N.; Paxton, L. J.

Midlatitude Ionospheric Dynamics and Disturbances. 2008. ed. / Anthea J. Coster; Tim Fuller-Rowell; Michael Mendillo; Roderick Heelis; Paul M. Kintner; Anthony J. Mannucci. Blackwell Publishing Ltd., 2008. p. 63-75 (Geophysical Monograph Series; Vol. 181).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Lu, G, Goncharenko, LP, Coster, AJ, Richmond, AD, Roble, RG, Aponte, N & Paxton, LJ 2008, A data-model comparative study of ionospheric positive storm phase in the midlatitude F region. in AJ Coster, T Fuller-Rowell, M Mendillo, R Heelis, PM Kintner & AJ Mannucci (eds), Midlatitude Ionospheric Dynamics and Disturbances. 2008. Geophysical Monograph Series, vol. 181, Blackwell Publishing Ltd., pp. 63-75. https://doi.org/10.1029/181GM07
Lu G, Goncharenko LP, Coster AJ, Richmond AD, Roble RG, Aponte N et al. A data-model comparative study of ionospheric positive storm phase in the midlatitude F region. In Coster AJ, Fuller-Rowell T, Mendillo M, Heelis R, Kintner PM, Mannucci AJ, editors, Midlatitude Ionospheric Dynamics and Disturbances. 2008. Blackwell Publishing Ltd. 2008. p. 63-75. (Geophysical Monograph Series). https://doi.org/10.1029/181GM07
Lu, G. ; Goncharenko, L. P. ; Coster, A. J. ; Richmond, A. D. ; Roble, R. G. ; Aponte, N. ; Paxton, L. J. / A data-model comparative study of ionospheric positive storm phase in the midlatitude F region. Midlatitude Ionospheric Dynamics and Disturbances. 2008. editor / Anthea J. Coster ; Tim Fuller-Rowell ; Michael Mendillo ; Roderick Heelis ; Paul M. Kintner ; Anthony J. Mannucci. Blackwell Publishing Ltd., 2008. pp. 63-75 (Geophysical Monograph Series).
@inproceedings{ebdce60e54304af0ae49f7b4c6d8678d,
title = "A data-model comparative study of ionospheric positive storm phase in the midlatitude F region",
abstract = "A strong positive storm phase was observed by both the Millstone Hill and Arecibo incoherent scatter radars during a moderate geomagnetic storm on 10 September 2005. The positive storm phase featured an interesting UT–altitude profile of the F region electron density enhancement that closely resembles the Greek letter L. The radar measurements showed that the uplift of the electron density peak height corresponded to a strong upward ion drift, whereas the subsequent falling of the peak height coincided with a downward ion drift. Using realistic, time-dependent ionospheric convection and auroral precipitation as input, the thermosphere–ionosphere electrodynamics general circulation model (TIEGCM) is able to reproduce the same L-like structure in the electron density profile, along with many large-scale features in electron temperature and vertical ion drift as observed by the radars. Over the 3-day period of 8–10 September, our simulation results show an error of 1{\%}–4{\%} for hmF2, electron, and ion temperatures at both radar locations. The estimated error for NmF2 is about 9{\%} at Millstone Hill and 19{\%} at Arecibo. However, the simulated vertical ion drifts are less accurate, with the normalized root-mean-square errors of 72{\%} at Millstone Hill and 52{\%} at Arecibo, due largely to model’s inability to capture the large temporal fluctuations measured by the radars. However, it reproduces reasonably well the overall large-scale variations during the 3-day period, including the storm-time-enhanced upward ion drift that is responsible for the interesting F region density profile. The model is also able to reproduce the temporal and spatial total electron content variations as shown in the global GPS maps. The comparison with the GUVI O/N2 is less satisfactory, although there is a general agreement in terms of relative O/N2 changes during the storm in the longitudinal sector between 60°W and 80°W where the radars are located. The detailed data–model comparison carried out in this study is helpful not only to validate the model but also to interpret the complex observations. The TIEGCM simulations reveal that it is the enhanced meridional neutral wind, not the penetration electric field, that is the primary cause of the L structure of the F region electron density profile.",
author = "G. Lu and Goncharenko, {L. P.} and Coster, {A. J.} and Richmond, {A. D.} and Roble, {R. G.} and N. Aponte and Paxton, {L. J.}",
year = "2008",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1029/181GM07",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780875904467",
series = "Geophysical Monograph Series",
publisher = "Blackwell Publishing Ltd.",
pages = "63--75",
editor = "Coster, {Anthea J.} and Tim Fuller-Rowell and Michael Mendillo and Roderick Heelis and Kintner, {Paul M.} and Mannucci, {Anthony J.}",
booktitle = "Midlatitude Ionospheric Dynamics and Disturbances. 2008",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - A data-model comparative study of ionospheric positive storm phase in the midlatitude F region

AU - Lu, G.

AU - Goncharenko, L. P.

AU - Coster, A. J.

AU - Richmond, A. D.

AU - Roble, R. G.

AU - Aponte, N.

AU - Paxton, L. J.

PY - 2008/1/1

Y1 - 2008/1/1

N2 - A strong positive storm phase was observed by both the Millstone Hill and Arecibo incoherent scatter radars during a moderate geomagnetic storm on 10 September 2005. The positive storm phase featured an interesting UT–altitude profile of the F region electron density enhancement that closely resembles the Greek letter L. The radar measurements showed that the uplift of the electron density peak height corresponded to a strong upward ion drift, whereas the subsequent falling of the peak height coincided with a downward ion drift. Using realistic, time-dependent ionospheric convection and auroral precipitation as input, the thermosphere–ionosphere electrodynamics general circulation model (TIEGCM) is able to reproduce the same L-like structure in the electron density profile, along with many large-scale features in electron temperature and vertical ion drift as observed by the radars. Over the 3-day period of 8–10 September, our simulation results show an error of 1%–4% for hmF2, electron, and ion temperatures at both radar locations. The estimated error for NmF2 is about 9% at Millstone Hill and 19% at Arecibo. However, the simulated vertical ion drifts are less accurate, with the normalized root-mean-square errors of 72% at Millstone Hill and 52% at Arecibo, due largely to model’s inability to capture the large temporal fluctuations measured by the radars. However, it reproduces reasonably well the overall large-scale variations during the 3-day period, including the storm-time-enhanced upward ion drift that is responsible for the interesting F region density profile. The model is also able to reproduce the temporal and spatial total electron content variations as shown in the global GPS maps. The comparison with the GUVI O/N2 is less satisfactory, although there is a general agreement in terms of relative O/N2 changes during the storm in the longitudinal sector between 60°W and 80°W where the radars are located. The detailed data–model comparison carried out in this study is helpful not only to validate the model but also to interpret the complex observations. The TIEGCM simulations reveal that it is the enhanced meridional neutral wind, not the penetration electric field, that is the primary cause of the L structure of the F region electron density profile.

AB - A strong positive storm phase was observed by both the Millstone Hill and Arecibo incoherent scatter radars during a moderate geomagnetic storm on 10 September 2005. The positive storm phase featured an interesting UT–altitude profile of the F region electron density enhancement that closely resembles the Greek letter L. The radar measurements showed that the uplift of the electron density peak height corresponded to a strong upward ion drift, whereas the subsequent falling of the peak height coincided with a downward ion drift. Using realistic, time-dependent ionospheric convection and auroral precipitation as input, the thermosphere–ionosphere electrodynamics general circulation model (TIEGCM) is able to reproduce the same L-like structure in the electron density profile, along with many large-scale features in electron temperature and vertical ion drift as observed by the radars. Over the 3-day period of 8–10 September, our simulation results show an error of 1%–4% for hmF2, electron, and ion temperatures at both radar locations. The estimated error for NmF2 is about 9% at Millstone Hill and 19% at Arecibo. However, the simulated vertical ion drifts are less accurate, with the normalized root-mean-square errors of 72% at Millstone Hill and 52% at Arecibo, due largely to model’s inability to capture the large temporal fluctuations measured by the radars. However, it reproduces reasonably well the overall large-scale variations during the 3-day period, including the storm-time-enhanced upward ion drift that is responsible for the interesting F region density profile. The model is also able to reproduce the temporal and spatial total electron content variations as shown in the global GPS maps. The comparison with the GUVI O/N2 is less satisfactory, although there is a general agreement in terms of relative O/N2 changes during the storm in the longitudinal sector between 60°W and 80°W where the radars are located. The detailed data–model comparison carried out in this study is helpful not only to validate the model but also to interpret the complex observations. The TIEGCM simulations reveal that it is the enhanced meridional neutral wind, not the penetration electric field, that is the primary cause of the L structure of the F region electron density profile.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=78650278917&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=78650278917&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1029/181GM07

DO - 10.1029/181GM07

M3 - Conference contribution

AN - SCOPUS:78650278917

SN - 9780875904467

T3 - Geophysical Monograph Series

SP - 63

EP - 75

BT - Midlatitude Ionospheric Dynamics and Disturbances. 2008

A2 - Coster, Anthea J.

A2 - Fuller-Rowell, Tim

A2 - Mendillo, Michael

A2 - Heelis, Roderick

A2 - Kintner, Paul M.

A2 - Mannucci, Anthony J.

PB - Blackwell Publishing Ltd.

ER -