APEX feedlot water quality simulation

J. R. Williams, W. L. Harman, M. Magre, U. Kizil, J. A. Lindley, G. Padmanabhan, Erda Wang

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

19 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

A manure erosion equation was developed and added to the APEX model for use in estimating nutrient losses from feedlots and manure application fields. The modified APEX was validated with data from feedlots near Bushland, Texas, and Carrington, North Dakota. The model was used to investigate feedlot management options on a hypothetical feedlot with realistic data. Vegetative filter strip (VFS) characteristics including 10%, 25%, 50%, and 100% FLRs (flow length ratios, i.e., filter flow length/feedlot flow length) and slopes of 1%, 5%, and 10% were considered. Combinations of these VFS characteristics were compared on two soil types: clay loam and fine sandy loam. Management options included three stocking rates (10, 15, and 20 m 2 head -1) and two clean-out intervals (90 and 180 d). Additionally, two climatic conditions (precipitation of 440 and 825 mm year -1) were simulated. Results from 50-year simulations indicate that a VFS downslope of the feedlot can greatly reduce nutrient loads. All three VFS characteristics (FLR, slope, and soil) were important in controlling organic N and P losses. The best organic N and P control was obtained from a VFS with maximum FLR (100%), minimum slope (1%), and a sandy loam soil. Results were similar for soluble N and P control except that VFS slope had little effect. The simulated management options (clean-out interval and stocking rate) were also effective in controlling nutrient losses. The climatic variable (annual precipitation) gave higher nutrient losses from the feedlot and the VFS with 825 mm than with 440 mm. Nutrient control efficiencies, CEs, 100.* (1.0 - nutrient loss from VFS/nutrient loss from feedlot) were calculated for all scenarios considered. The VFSs on sandy loam soil with FLRs equal to or greater than 50% gave the highest CEs for both soluble and organic nutrients. Other factors including VFS slope, clean-out interval, and stocking rate had marginal impacts on CE. For soluble nutrients, CE is inversely related to annual precipitation. Thus, it is important to locate feedlots in areas with low precipitation and to provide a well designed VFS. The APEX model with the new manure erosion equation provides a tool for designing VFSs for controlling nutrient losses from feedlots.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)61-73
Number of pages13
JournalTransactions of the ASABE
Volume49
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - Jan 1 2006

Fingerprint

filter strips
Water Quality
feedlots
Nutrients
Water quality
water quality
filter
Food
nutrient loss
nutrients
simulation
Manure
Manures
Soil
stocking rate
animal manures
sandy loam
Soils
manure
nutrient

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Forestry
  • Food Science
  • Biomedical Engineering
  • Agronomy and Crop Science
  • Soil Science

Cite this

Williams, J. R., Harman, W. L., Magre, M., Kizil, U., Lindley, J. A., Padmanabhan, G., & Wang, E. (2006). APEX feedlot water quality simulation. Transactions of the ASABE, 49(1), 61-73.

APEX feedlot water quality simulation. / Williams, J. R.; Harman, W. L.; Magre, M.; Kizil, U.; Lindley, J. A.; Padmanabhan, G.; Wang, Erda.

In: Transactions of the ASABE, Vol. 49, No. 1, 01.01.2006, p. 61-73.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Williams, JR, Harman, WL, Magre, M, Kizil, U, Lindley, JA, Padmanabhan, G & Wang, E 2006, 'APEX feedlot water quality simulation', Transactions of the ASABE, vol. 49, no. 1, pp. 61-73.
Williams JR, Harman WL, Magre M, Kizil U, Lindley JA, Padmanabhan G et al. APEX feedlot water quality simulation. Transactions of the ASABE. 2006 Jan 1;49(1):61-73.
Williams, J. R. ; Harman, W. L. ; Magre, M. ; Kizil, U. ; Lindley, J. A. ; Padmanabhan, G. ; Wang, Erda. / APEX feedlot water quality simulation. In: Transactions of the ASABE. 2006 ; Vol. 49, No. 1. pp. 61-73.
@article{5cb11f9cf0774c258da2e941c7ec0745,
title = "APEX feedlot water quality simulation",
abstract = "A manure erosion equation was developed and added to the APEX model for use in estimating nutrient losses from feedlots and manure application fields. The modified APEX was validated with data from feedlots near Bushland, Texas, and Carrington, North Dakota. The model was used to investigate feedlot management options on a hypothetical feedlot with realistic data. Vegetative filter strip (VFS) characteristics including 10{\%}, 25{\%}, 50{\%}, and 100{\%} FLRs (flow length ratios, i.e., filter flow length/feedlot flow length) and slopes of 1{\%}, 5{\%}, and 10{\%} were considered. Combinations of these VFS characteristics were compared on two soil types: clay loam and fine sandy loam. Management options included three stocking rates (10, 15, and 20 m 2 head -1) and two clean-out intervals (90 and 180 d). Additionally, two climatic conditions (precipitation of 440 and 825 mm year -1) were simulated. Results from 50-year simulations indicate that a VFS downslope of the feedlot can greatly reduce nutrient loads. All three VFS characteristics (FLR, slope, and soil) were important in controlling organic N and P losses. The best organic N and P control was obtained from a VFS with maximum FLR (100{\%}), minimum slope (1{\%}), and a sandy loam soil. Results were similar for soluble N and P control except that VFS slope had little effect. The simulated management options (clean-out interval and stocking rate) were also effective in controlling nutrient losses. The climatic variable (annual precipitation) gave higher nutrient losses from the feedlot and the VFS with 825 mm than with 440 mm. Nutrient control efficiencies, CEs, 100.* (1.0 - nutrient loss from VFS/nutrient loss from feedlot) were calculated for all scenarios considered. The VFSs on sandy loam soil with FLRs equal to or greater than 50{\%} gave the highest CEs for both soluble and organic nutrients. Other factors including VFS slope, clean-out interval, and stocking rate had marginal impacts on CE. For soluble nutrients, CE is inversely related to annual precipitation. Thus, it is important to locate feedlots in areas with low precipitation and to provide a well designed VFS. The APEX model with the new manure erosion equation provides a tool for designing VFSs for controlling nutrient losses from feedlots.",
author = "Williams, {J. R.} and Harman, {W. L.} and M. Magre and U. Kizil and Lindley, {J. A.} and G. Padmanabhan and Erda Wang",
year = "2006",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "49",
pages = "61--73",
journal = "Transactions of the ASABE",
issn = "2151-0032",
publisher = "American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - APEX feedlot water quality simulation

AU - Williams, J. R.

AU - Harman, W. L.

AU - Magre, M.

AU - Kizil, U.

AU - Lindley, J. A.

AU - Padmanabhan, G.

AU - Wang, Erda

PY - 2006/1/1

Y1 - 2006/1/1

N2 - A manure erosion equation was developed and added to the APEX model for use in estimating nutrient losses from feedlots and manure application fields. The modified APEX was validated with data from feedlots near Bushland, Texas, and Carrington, North Dakota. The model was used to investigate feedlot management options on a hypothetical feedlot with realistic data. Vegetative filter strip (VFS) characteristics including 10%, 25%, 50%, and 100% FLRs (flow length ratios, i.e., filter flow length/feedlot flow length) and slopes of 1%, 5%, and 10% were considered. Combinations of these VFS characteristics were compared on two soil types: clay loam and fine sandy loam. Management options included three stocking rates (10, 15, and 20 m 2 head -1) and two clean-out intervals (90 and 180 d). Additionally, two climatic conditions (precipitation of 440 and 825 mm year -1) were simulated. Results from 50-year simulations indicate that a VFS downslope of the feedlot can greatly reduce nutrient loads. All three VFS characteristics (FLR, slope, and soil) were important in controlling organic N and P losses. The best organic N and P control was obtained from a VFS with maximum FLR (100%), minimum slope (1%), and a sandy loam soil. Results were similar for soluble N and P control except that VFS slope had little effect. The simulated management options (clean-out interval and stocking rate) were also effective in controlling nutrient losses. The climatic variable (annual precipitation) gave higher nutrient losses from the feedlot and the VFS with 825 mm than with 440 mm. Nutrient control efficiencies, CEs, 100.* (1.0 - nutrient loss from VFS/nutrient loss from feedlot) were calculated for all scenarios considered. The VFSs on sandy loam soil with FLRs equal to or greater than 50% gave the highest CEs for both soluble and organic nutrients. Other factors including VFS slope, clean-out interval, and stocking rate had marginal impacts on CE. For soluble nutrients, CE is inversely related to annual precipitation. Thus, it is important to locate feedlots in areas with low precipitation and to provide a well designed VFS. The APEX model with the new manure erosion equation provides a tool for designing VFSs for controlling nutrient losses from feedlots.

AB - A manure erosion equation was developed and added to the APEX model for use in estimating nutrient losses from feedlots and manure application fields. The modified APEX was validated with data from feedlots near Bushland, Texas, and Carrington, North Dakota. The model was used to investigate feedlot management options on a hypothetical feedlot with realistic data. Vegetative filter strip (VFS) characteristics including 10%, 25%, 50%, and 100% FLRs (flow length ratios, i.e., filter flow length/feedlot flow length) and slopes of 1%, 5%, and 10% were considered. Combinations of these VFS characteristics were compared on two soil types: clay loam and fine sandy loam. Management options included three stocking rates (10, 15, and 20 m 2 head -1) and two clean-out intervals (90 and 180 d). Additionally, two climatic conditions (precipitation of 440 and 825 mm year -1) were simulated. Results from 50-year simulations indicate that a VFS downslope of the feedlot can greatly reduce nutrient loads. All three VFS characteristics (FLR, slope, and soil) were important in controlling organic N and P losses. The best organic N and P control was obtained from a VFS with maximum FLR (100%), minimum slope (1%), and a sandy loam soil. Results were similar for soluble N and P control except that VFS slope had little effect. The simulated management options (clean-out interval and stocking rate) were also effective in controlling nutrient losses. The climatic variable (annual precipitation) gave higher nutrient losses from the feedlot and the VFS with 825 mm than with 440 mm. Nutrient control efficiencies, CEs, 100.* (1.0 - nutrient loss from VFS/nutrient loss from feedlot) were calculated for all scenarios considered. The VFSs on sandy loam soil with FLRs equal to or greater than 50% gave the highest CEs for both soluble and organic nutrients. Other factors including VFS slope, clean-out interval, and stocking rate had marginal impacts on CE. For soluble nutrients, CE is inversely related to annual precipitation. Thus, it is important to locate feedlots in areas with low precipitation and to provide a well designed VFS. The APEX model with the new manure erosion equation provides a tool for designing VFSs for controlling nutrient losses from feedlots.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33645458254&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33645458254&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 49

SP - 61

EP - 73

JO - Transactions of the ASABE

JF - Transactions of the ASABE

SN - 2151-0032

IS - 1

ER -