The characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians in Japan: A qualitative study

Makoto Kikukawa, Hiromi Nabeta, Maiko Ono, Sei Emura, Yasutomo Oda, Shunzo Koizumi, Takanobu Sakemi

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

9 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: It is not known whether the characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians are the same in Western countries as in non-Western countries including Japan. The objective of this study was to identify the characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians in Japan, a non-Western country, and to compare the results with those obtained in Western countries. Methods. Data for this qualitative research were collected using semi-structured focus group interviews. Focus group transcripts were independently analyzed and coded by three authors. Residents were recruited by maximum variation sampling until thematic saturation was achieved. Results: Twenty-three residents participated in five focus group interviews regarding the perceived characteristics of a good clinical teacher in Japan. The 197 descriptions of characteristics that were identified were grouped into 30 themes. The most commonly identified theme was "provided sufficient support", followed by "presented residents with chances to think", "provided feedback", and "provided specific indications of areas needing improvement". Using Sutkin's main categories (teacher, physician, and human characteristics), 24 of the 30 themes were categorized as teacher characteristics, 6 as physician characteristics, and none as human characteristics. Conclusions: "Medical knowledge" of teachers was not identified as a concern of residents, and "clinical competence of teachers" was not emphasized, whereas these were the two most commonly recorded themes in Sutkin's study. Our results suggest that Japanese and Western resident physicians place emphasis on different characteristics of their teachers. We speculate that such perceptions are influenced by educational systems, educational settings, and culture. Globalization of medical education is important, but it is also important to consider differences in educational systems, local settings, and culture when evaluating clinical teachers.

Original languageEnglish
Article number100
JournalBMC Medical Education
Volume13
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 7 2013

Fingerprint

Japan
physician
resident
teacher
educational system
Group
educational setting
interview
qualitative research
indication
globalization
education

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Education

Cite this

The characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians in Japan : A qualitative study. / Kikukawa, Makoto; Nabeta, Hiromi; Ono, Maiko; Emura, Sei; Oda, Yasutomo; Koizumi, Shunzo; Sakemi, Takanobu.

In: BMC Medical Education, Vol. 13, No. 1, 100, 07.08.2013.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Kikukawa, Makoto ; Nabeta, Hiromi ; Ono, Maiko ; Emura, Sei ; Oda, Yasutomo ; Koizumi, Shunzo ; Sakemi, Takanobu. / The characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians in Japan : A qualitative study. In: BMC Medical Education. 2013 ; Vol. 13, No. 1.
@article{8908e05b62e0463d89dc4dfefdcc6fc2,
title = "The characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians in Japan: A qualitative study",
abstract = "Background: It is not known whether the characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians are the same in Western countries as in non-Western countries including Japan. The objective of this study was to identify the characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians in Japan, a non-Western country, and to compare the results with those obtained in Western countries. Methods. Data for this qualitative research were collected using semi-structured focus group interviews. Focus group transcripts were independently analyzed and coded by three authors. Residents were recruited by maximum variation sampling until thematic saturation was achieved. Results: Twenty-three residents participated in five focus group interviews regarding the perceived characteristics of a good clinical teacher in Japan. The 197 descriptions of characteristics that were identified were grouped into 30 themes. The most commonly identified theme was {"}provided sufficient support{"}, followed by {"}presented residents with chances to think{"}, {"}provided feedback{"}, and {"}provided specific indications of areas needing improvement{"}. Using Sutkin's main categories (teacher, physician, and human characteristics), 24 of the 30 themes were categorized as teacher characteristics, 6 as physician characteristics, and none as human characteristics. Conclusions: {"}Medical knowledge{"} of teachers was not identified as a concern of residents, and {"}clinical competence of teachers{"} was not emphasized, whereas these were the two most commonly recorded themes in Sutkin's study. Our results suggest that Japanese and Western resident physicians place emphasis on different characteristics of their teachers. We speculate that such perceptions are influenced by educational systems, educational settings, and culture. Globalization of medical education is important, but it is also important to consider differences in educational systems, local settings, and culture when evaluating clinical teachers.",
author = "Makoto Kikukawa and Hiromi Nabeta and Maiko Ono and Sei Emura and Yasutomo Oda and Shunzo Koizumi and Takanobu Sakemi",
year = "2013",
month = "8",
day = "7",
doi = "10.1186/1472-6920-13-100",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
journal = "BMC Medical Education",
issn = "1472-6920",
publisher = "BioMed Central",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians in Japan

T2 - A qualitative study

AU - Kikukawa, Makoto

AU - Nabeta, Hiromi

AU - Ono, Maiko

AU - Emura, Sei

AU - Oda, Yasutomo

AU - Koizumi, Shunzo

AU - Sakemi, Takanobu

PY - 2013/8/7

Y1 - 2013/8/7

N2 - Background: It is not known whether the characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians are the same in Western countries as in non-Western countries including Japan. The objective of this study was to identify the characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians in Japan, a non-Western country, and to compare the results with those obtained in Western countries. Methods. Data for this qualitative research were collected using semi-structured focus group interviews. Focus group transcripts were independently analyzed and coded by three authors. Residents were recruited by maximum variation sampling until thematic saturation was achieved. Results: Twenty-three residents participated in five focus group interviews regarding the perceived characteristics of a good clinical teacher in Japan. The 197 descriptions of characteristics that were identified were grouped into 30 themes. The most commonly identified theme was "provided sufficient support", followed by "presented residents with chances to think", "provided feedback", and "provided specific indications of areas needing improvement". Using Sutkin's main categories (teacher, physician, and human characteristics), 24 of the 30 themes were categorized as teacher characteristics, 6 as physician characteristics, and none as human characteristics. Conclusions: "Medical knowledge" of teachers was not identified as a concern of residents, and "clinical competence of teachers" was not emphasized, whereas these were the two most commonly recorded themes in Sutkin's study. Our results suggest that Japanese and Western resident physicians place emphasis on different characteristics of their teachers. We speculate that such perceptions are influenced by educational systems, educational settings, and culture. Globalization of medical education is important, but it is also important to consider differences in educational systems, local settings, and culture when evaluating clinical teachers.

AB - Background: It is not known whether the characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians are the same in Western countries as in non-Western countries including Japan. The objective of this study was to identify the characteristics of a good clinical teacher as perceived by resident physicians in Japan, a non-Western country, and to compare the results with those obtained in Western countries. Methods. Data for this qualitative research were collected using semi-structured focus group interviews. Focus group transcripts were independently analyzed and coded by three authors. Residents were recruited by maximum variation sampling until thematic saturation was achieved. Results: Twenty-three residents participated in five focus group interviews regarding the perceived characteristics of a good clinical teacher in Japan. The 197 descriptions of characteristics that were identified were grouped into 30 themes. The most commonly identified theme was "provided sufficient support", followed by "presented residents with chances to think", "provided feedback", and "provided specific indications of areas needing improvement". Using Sutkin's main categories (teacher, physician, and human characteristics), 24 of the 30 themes were categorized as teacher characteristics, 6 as physician characteristics, and none as human characteristics. Conclusions: "Medical knowledge" of teachers was not identified as a concern of residents, and "clinical competence of teachers" was not emphasized, whereas these were the two most commonly recorded themes in Sutkin's study. Our results suggest that Japanese and Western resident physicians place emphasis on different characteristics of their teachers. We speculate that such perceptions are influenced by educational systems, educational settings, and culture. Globalization of medical education is important, but it is also important to consider differences in educational systems, local settings, and culture when evaluating clinical teachers.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84880943044&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84880943044&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1186/1472-6920-13-100

DO - 10.1186/1472-6920-13-100

M3 - Article

C2 - 23883367

AN - SCOPUS:84880943044

VL - 13

JO - BMC Medical Education

JF - BMC Medical Education

SN - 1472-6920

IS - 1

M1 - 100

ER -