Two approaches for the gravitational self-force in black hole spacetime: Comparison of numerical results

Norichika Sago, Leor Barack, Steven Detweiler

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

89 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Recently, two independent calculations have been presented of finite-mass ("self-force") effects on the orbit of a point mass around a Schwarzschild black hole. While both computations are based on the standard mode-sum method, they differ in several technical aspects, which makes comparison between their results difficult-but also interesting. Barack and Sago invoke the notion of a self-accelerated motion in a background spacetime, and perform a direct calculation of the local self-force in the Lorenz gauge (using numerical evolution of the perturbation equations in the time domain); Detweiler describes the motion in terms a geodesic orbit of a (smooth) perturbed spacetime, and calculates the metric perturbation in the Regge-Wheeler gauge (using frequency-domain numerical analysis). Here we establish a formal correspondence between the two analyses, and demonstrate the consistency of their numerical results. Specifically, we compare the value of the conservative O(μ) shift in ut (where μ is the particle's mass and ut is the Schwarzschild t component of the particle's four-velocity), suitably mapped between the two orbital descriptions and adjusted for gauge. We find that the two analyses yield the same value for this shift within mere fractional differences of ∼10-5-10-7 (depending on the orbital radius)-comparable with the estimated numerical error.

Original languageEnglish
Article number124024
JournalPhysical Review D - Particles, Fields, Gravitation and Cosmology
Volume78
Issue number12
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2 2008
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

orbits
orbitals
perturbation
particle mass
shift
numerical analysis
radii

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Nuclear and High Energy Physics

Cite this

Two approaches for the gravitational self-force in black hole spacetime : Comparison of numerical results. / Sago, Norichika; Barack, Leor; Detweiler, Steven.

In: Physical Review D - Particles, Fields, Gravitation and Cosmology, Vol. 78, No. 12, 124024, 02.12.2008.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{4f7120e512b94eeb9c5e3b7e75978ccd,
title = "Two approaches for the gravitational self-force in black hole spacetime: Comparison of numerical results",
abstract = "Recently, two independent calculations have been presented of finite-mass ({"}self-force{"}) effects on the orbit of a point mass around a Schwarzschild black hole. While both computations are based on the standard mode-sum method, they differ in several technical aspects, which makes comparison between their results difficult-but also interesting. Barack and Sago invoke the notion of a self-accelerated motion in a background spacetime, and perform a direct calculation of the local self-force in the Lorenz gauge (using numerical evolution of the perturbation equations in the time domain); Detweiler describes the motion in terms a geodesic orbit of a (smooth) perturbed spacetime, and calculates the metric perturbation in the Regge-Wheeler gauge (using frequency-domain numerical analysis). Here we establish a formal correspondence between the two analyses, and demonstrate the consistency of their numerical results. Specifically, we compare the value of the conservative O(μ) shift in ut (where μ is the particle's mass and ut is the Schwarzschild t component of the particle's four-velocity), suitably mapped between the two orbital descriptions and adjusted for gauge. We find that the two analyses yield the same value for this shift within mere fractional differences of ∼10-5-10-7 (depending on the orbital radius)-comparable with the estimated numerical error.",
author = "Norichika Sago and Leor Barack and Steven Detweiler",
year = "2008",
month = "12",
day = "2",
doi = "10.1103/PhysRevD.78.124024",
language = "English",
volume = "78",
journal = "Physical Review D - Particles, Fields, Gravitation and Cosmology",
issn = "1550-7998",
number = "12",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Two approaches for the gravitational self-force in black hole spacetime

T2 - Comparison of numerical results

AU - Sago, Norichika

AU - Barack, Leor

AU - Detweiler, Steven

PY - 2008/12/2

Y1 - 2008/12/2

N2 - Recently, two independent calculations have been presented of finite-mass ("self-force") effects on the orbit of a point mass around a Schwarzschild black hole. While both computations are based on the standard mode-sum method, they differ in several technical aspects, which makes comparison between their results difficult-but also interesting. Barack and Sago invoke the notion of a self-accelerated motion in a background spacetime, and perform a direct calculation of the local self-force in the Lorenz gauge (using numerical evolution of the perturbation equations in the time domain); Detweiler describes the motion in terms a geodesic orbit of a (smooth) perturbed spacetime, and calculates the metric perturbation in the Regge-Wheeler gauge (using frequency-domain numerical analysis). Here we establish a formal correspondence between the two analyses, and demonstrate the consistency of their numerical results. Specifically, we compare the value of the conservative O(μ) shift in ut (where μ is the particle's mass and ut is the Schwarzschild t component of the particle's four-velocity), suitably mapped between the two orbital descriptions and adjusted for gauge. We find that the two analyses yield the same value for this shift within mere fractional differences of ∼10-5-10-7 (depending on the orbital radius)-comparable with the estimated numerical error.

AB - Recently, two independent calculations have been presented of finite-mass ("self-force") effects on the orbit of a point mass around a Schwarzschild black hole. While both computations are based on the standard mode-sum method, they differ in several technical aspects, which makes comparison between their results difficult-but also interesting. Barack and Sago invoke the notion of a self-accelerated motion in a background spacetime, and perform a direct calculation of the local self-force in the Lorenz gauge (using numerical evolution of the perturbation equations in the time domain); Detweiler describes the motion in terms a geodesic orbit of a (smooth) perturbed spacetime, and calculates the metric perturbation in the Regge-Wheeler gauge (using frequency-domain numerical analysis). Here we establish a formal correspondence between the two analyses, and demonstrate the consistency of their numerical results. Specifically, we compare the value of the conservative O(μ) shift in ut (where μ is the particle's mass and ut is the Schwarzschild t component of the particle's four-velocity), suitably mapped between the two orbital descriptions and adjusted for gauge. We find that the two analyses yield the same value for this shift within mere fractional differences of ∼10-5-10-7 (depending on the orbital radius)-comparable with the estimated numerical error.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=58949103287&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=58949103287&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1103/PhysRevD.78.124024

DO - 10.1103/PhysRevD.78.124024

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:58949103287

VL - 78

JO - Physical Review D - Particles, Fields, Gravitation and Cosmology

JF - Physical Review D - Particles, Fields, Gravitation and Cosmology

SN - 1550-7998

IS - 12

M1 - 124024

ER -