Variability of treatment planning of seed implantation: A Japanese multicenter simulation study

Hiromichi Ishiyama, Masahiro Nakano, Kazuhito Toya, Ryuichi Kota, Koyo Kikuchi, Takahiro Yamaguchi, Naoaki Kono, Shogo Kawakami, Yuki Tsutsumi, Tomoki Tanaka, Takahisa Eriguchi, Ohga Saiji, Toshihiro Yamaguchi, Yoshiaki Takakawa, Masashi Morita, Norihisa Katayama, Toshio Ohashi, Manabu Aoki, Atsunori Yorozu, Siro Saito

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Purpose This multicenter study was conducted to evaluate the current variability of treatment planning of seed implantation in Japanese centers and the feasibility of two virtual trials. Methods and Materials Two types of contour data were sent to 12 radiation oncologists with a request letter that asked them to make treatment plans on the data in the same manner as in their own practice. Five of the 12 radiation oncologists were asked to participate in the two virtual trials in which the D90 (dose to the hottest 90% of prostate volume) was 1) required to be set at just 180 Gy and 2) increased as much as possible without violating other limitations. Results A relatively high dose with a small deviation was irradiated to the prostate in Japanese centers (mean D90 = 188 Gy; SD = 10 Gy). In the virtual trials, all five physicians could achieve 180 Gy for the D90 with a very small deviation, although the urethral dose showed relatively large deviations. Dose escalation without increase of urethral dose or V150 was difficult, although the rectum could be spared by most of the physicians. Conclusion Our study showed a relatively high dose with a small deviation was prescribed to the prostate in Japanese centers. Consolidated protocols such as D90 = 180 Gy could be available for future trials. Meanwhile, our study suggested that some cautions might be needed for urethral dose and the V150, even when a relatively low D90 was requested.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1013-1020
Number of pages8
JournalBrachytherapy
Volume16
Issue number5
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Sep 1 2017

Fingerprint

Multicenter Studies
Prostate
Seeds
Physicians
Rectum
Therapeutics
Radiation Oncologists

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Oncology
  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

Ishiyama, H., Nakano, M., Toya, K., Kota, R., Kikuchi, K., Yamaguchi, T., ... Saito, S. (2017). Variability of treatment planning of seed implantation: A Japanese multicenter simulation study. Brachytherapy, 16(5), 1013-1020. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brachy.2017.05.007

Variability of treatment planning of seed implantation : A Japanese multicenter simulation study. / Ishiyama, Hiromichi; Nakano, Masahiro; Toya, Kazuhito; Kota, Ryuichi; Kikuchi, Koyo; Yamaguchi, Takahiro; Kono, Naoaki; Kawakami, Shogo; Tsutsumi, Yuki; Tanaka, Tomoki; Eriguchi, Takahisa; Saiji, Ohga; Yamaguchi, Toshihiro; Takakawa, Yoshiaki; Morita, Masashi; Katayama, Norihisa; Ohashi, Toshio; Aoki, Manabu; Yorozu, Atsunori; Saito, Siro.

In: Brachytherapy, Vol. 16, No. 5, 01.09.2017, p. 1013-1020.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ishiyama, H, Nakano, M, Toya, K, Kota, R, Kikuchi, K, Yamaguchi, T, Kono, N, Kawakami, S, Tsutsumi, Y, Tanaka, T, Eriguchi, T, Saiji, O, Yamaguchi, T, Takakawa, Y, Morita, M, Katayama, N, Ohashi, T, Aoki, M, Yorozu, A & Saito, S 2017, 'Variability of treatment planning of seed implantation: A Japanese multicenter simulation study', Brachytherapy, vol. 16, no. 5, pp. 1013-1020. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brachy.2017.05.007
Ishiyama, Hiromichi ; Nakano, Masahiro ; Toya, Kazuhito ; Kota, Ryuichi ; Kikuchi, Koyo ; Yamaguchi, Takahiro ; Kono, Naoaki ; Kawakami, Shogo ; Tsutsumi, Yuki ; Tanaka, Tomoki ; Eriguchi, Takahisa ; Saiji, Ohga ; Yamaguchi, Toshihiro ; Takakawa, Yoshiaki ; Morita, Masashi ; Katayama, Norihisa ; Ohashi, Toshio ; Aoki, Manabu ; Yorozu, Atsunori ; Saito, Siro. / Variability of treatment planning of seed implantation : A Japanese multicenter simulation study. In: Brachytherapy. 2017 ; Vol. 16, No. 5. pp. 1013-1020.
@article{665614fe541047b0b6af0f1a93745f2d,
title = "Variability of treatment planning of seed implantation: A Japanese multicenter simulation study",
abstract = "Purpose This multicenter study was conducted to evaluate the current variability of treatment planning of seed implantation in Japanese centers and the feasibility of two virtual trials. Methods and Materials Two types of contour data were sent to 12 radiation oncologists with a request letter that asked them to make treatment plans on the data in the same manner as in their own practice. Five of the 12 radiation oncologists were asked to participate in the two virtual trials in which the D90 (dose to the hottest 90{\%} of prostate volume) was 1) required to be set at just 180 Gy and 2) increased as much as possible without violating other limitations. Results A relatively high dose with a small deviation was irradiated to the prostate in Japanese centers (mean D90 = 188 Gy; SD = 10 Gy). In the virtual trials, all five physicians could achieve 180 Gy for the D90 with a very small deviation, although the urethral dose showed relatively large deviations. Dose escalation without increase of urethral dose or V150 was difficult, although the rectum could be spared by most of the physicians. Conclusion Our study showed a relatively high dose with a small deviation was prescribed to the prostate in Japanese centers. Consolidated protocols such as D90 = 180 Gy could be available for future trials. Meanwhile, our study suggested that some cautions might be needed for urethral dose and the V150, even when a relatively low D90 was requested.",
author = "Hiromichi Ishiyama and Masahiro Nakano and Kazuhito Toya and Ryuichi Kota and Koyo Kikuchi and Takahiro Yamaguchi and Naoaki Kono and Shogo Kawakami and Yuki Tsutsumi and Tomoki Tanaka and Takahisa Eriguchi and Ohga Saiji and Toshihiro Yamaguchi and Yoshiaki Takakawa and Masashi Morita and Norihisa Katayama and Toshio Ohashi and Manabu Aoki and Atsunori Yorozu and Siro Saito",
year = "2017",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.brachy.2017.05.007",
language = "English",
volume = "16",
pages = "1013--1020",
journal = "Brachytherapy",
issn = "1538-4721",
publisher = "Elsevier Inc.",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Variability of treatment planning of seed implantation

T2 - A Japanese multicenter simulation study

AU - Ishiyama, Hiromichi

AU - Nakano, Masahiro

AU - Toya, Kazuhito

AU - Kota, Ryuichi

AU - Kikuchi, Koyo

AU - Yamaguchi, Takahiro

AU - Kono, Naoaki

AU - Kawakami, Shogo

AU - Tsutsumi, Yuki

AU - Tanaka, Tomoki

AU - Eriguchi, Takahisa

AU - Saiji, Ohga

AU - Yamaguchi, Toshihiro

AU - Takakawa, Yoshiaki

AU - Morita, Masashi

AU - Katayama, Norihisa

AU - Ohashi, Toshio

AU - Aoki, Manabu

AU - Yorozu, Atsunori

AU - Saito, Siro

PY - 2017/9/1

Y1 - 2017/9/1

N2 - Purpose This multicenter study was conducted to evaluate the current variability of treatment planning of seed implantation in Japanese centers and the feasibility of two virtual trials. Methods and Materials Two types of contour data were sent to 12 radiation oncologists with a request letter that asked them to make treatment plans on the data in the same manner as in their own practice. Five of the 12 radiation oncologists were asked to participate in the two virtual trials in which the D90 (dose to the hottest 90% of prostate volume) was 1) required to be set at just 180 Gy and 2) increased as much as possible without violating other limitations. Results A relatively high dose with a small deviation was irradiated to the prostate in Japanese centers (mean D90 = 188 Gy; SD = 10 Gy). In the virtual trials, all five physicians could achieve 180 Gy for the D90 with a very small deviation, although the urethral dose showed relatively large deviations. Dose escalation without increase of urethral dose or V150 was difficult, although the rectum could be spared by most of the physicians. Conclusion Our study showed a relatively high dose with a small deviation was prescribed to the prostate in Japanese centers. Consolidated protocols such as D90 = 180 Gy could be available for future trials. Meanwhile, our study suggested that some cautions might be needed for urethral dose and the V150, even when a relatively low D90 was requested.

AB - Purpose This multicenter study was conducted to evaluate the current variability of treatment planning of seed implantation in Japanese centers and the feasibility of two virtual trials. Methods and Materials Two types of contour data were sent to 12 radiation oncologists with a request letter that asked them to make treatment plans on the data in the same manner as in their own practice. Five of the 12 radiation oncologists were asked to participate in the two virtual trials in which the D90 (dose to the hottest 90% of prostate volume) was 1) required to be set at just 180 Gy and 2) increased as much as possible without violating other limitations. Results A relatively high dose with a small deviation was irradiated to the prostate in Japanese centers (mean D90 = 188 Gy; SD = 10 Gy). In the virtual trials, all five physicians could achieve 180 Gy for the D90 with a very small deviation, although the urethral dose showed relatively large deviations. Dose escalation without increase of urethral dose or V150 was difficult, although the rectum could be spared by most of the physicians. Conclusion Our study showed a relatively high dose with a small deviation was prescribed to the prostate in Japanese centers. Consolidated protocols such as D90 = 180 Gy could be available for future trials. Meanwhile, our study suggested that some cautions might be needed for urethral dose and the V150, even when a relatively low D90 was requested.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85020637417&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85020637417&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.brachy.2017.05.007

DO - 10.1016/j.brachy.2017.05.007

M3 - Article

C2 - 28623085

AN - SCOPUS:85020637417

VL - 16

SP - 1013

EP - 1020

JO - Brachytherapy

JF - Brachytherapy

SN - 1538-4721

IS - 5

ER -