Less is more: lemurs (Eulemur spp.) may benefit from loss of trichromatic vision

Rachel L. Jacobs, Carrie C. Veilleux, Edward E. Louis, James P. Herrera, Chihiro Hiramatsu, David C. Frankel, Mitchell T. Irwin, Amanda D. Melin, Brenda J. Bradley

研究成果: ジャーナルへの寄稿記事

抄録

Abstract: Vertebrate color vision is an ideal system for studying the gains and losses of genetic variation across lineages and impacts on behavior. Among placental mammals, trichromatic vision is unique to primates and is argued to be adaptive for foraging on reddish food. However, trichromacy is variably present in lemurs, including species within the cathemeral genus Eulemur, due to inter- and intra-specific variation in X-linked opsin genes. Although this variation could result from genetic drift, it could also reflect ecological adaptation. To understand ecological contributions to color vision variation, we examined cone opsin genes of 11 Eulemur species. We found that only E. flavifrons and E. macaco have polymorphic trichromacy. Most dichromatic species have an “M” (green-shifted) opsin; uniquely, one species (E. rubriventer) has dichromacy based on an “L” (red-shifted) opsin. This latter result appears to represent loss of polymorphic trichromacy from a dichromatic (M opsin) or polymorphic Eulemur ancestor. To address potential ecological explanations for opsin variation, we studied the dietary behavior of wild E. rubriventer and collected reflectance spectra from plant species consumed. Visual models suggest that trichromacy should provide an advantage for detecting reddish foods; however, luminance contrasts were greatest for dichromats with the L opsin. As E. rubriventer are often active in low-light rainforest conditions, luminance cues may be relatively important, which could favor the L opsin, while also leading to relaxed selection on, or selection against, trichromacy. The presence of different opsin alleles across Eulemur species could represent adaptations related to diet, activity pattern, or habitat. Significance statement: Loss of genetic variation, often thought to be maladaptive, can occur through natural selection. Among primates, some species have trichromatic color vision, the ability to distinguish reddish and greenish hues; others are red-green colorblind (dichromatic). We examined adaptive explanations for color vision differences by studying cone opsin genes and behavior in wild lemurs (Eulemur)—a genus that is active both day and night. We found that color vision is variable in Eulemur species, and full trichromatic vision was likely lost in at least one lineage. Foraging ecology of dichromatic Eulemur rubriventer indicates that trichromatic vision should be advantageous for foraging on reddish foods, but brightness cues are more salient to this species’ vision. We suggest brightness may be more important than color to this species, particularly at night, and loss of trichromacy could be adaptive in some lemurs.

元の言語英語
記事番号22
ジャーナルBehavioral Ecology and Sociobiology
73
発行部数2
DOI
出版物ステータス出版済み - 2 1 2019

Fingerprint

opsin
Lemuridae
color vision
cones (retina)
foraging
primate
food
genetic variation
gene
Primates
Eulemur
loss
genetic drift
intraspecific variation
activity pattern
genes
natural selection
ancestry
rainforest
eating habits

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
  • Animal Science and Zoology

これを引用

Jacobs, R. L., Veilleux, C. C., Louis, E. E., Herrera, J. P., Hiramatsu, C., Frankel, D. C., ... Bradley, B. J. (2019). Less is more: lemurs (Eulemur spp.) may benefit from loss of trichromatic vision. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 73(2), [22]. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-018-2629-9

Less is more : lemurs (Eulemur spp.) may benefit from loss of trichromatic vision. / Jacobs, Rachel L.; Veilleux, Carrie C.; Louis, Edward E.; Herrera, James P.; Hiramatsu, Chihiro; Frankel, David C.; Irwin, Mitchell T.; Melin, Amanda D.; Bradley, Brenda J.

:: Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 巻 73, 番号 2, 22, 01.02.2019.

研究成果: ジャーナルへの寄稿記事

Jacobs, RL, Veilleux, CC, Louis, EE, Herrera, JP, Hiramatsu, C, Frankel, DC, Irwin, MT, Melin, AD & Bradley, BJ 2019, 'Less is more: lemurs (Eulemur spp.) may benefit from loss of trichromatic vision' Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 巻. 73, 番号 2, 22. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-018-2629-9
Jacobs, Rachel L. ; Veilleux, Carrie C. ; Louis, Edward E. ; Herrera, James P. ; Hiramatsu, Chihiro ; Frankel, David C. ; Irwin, Mitchell T. ; Melin, Amanda D. ; Bradley, Brenda J. / Less is more : lemurs (Eulemur spp.) may benefit from loss of trichromatic vision. :: Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology. 2019 ; 巻 73, 番号 2.
@article{4488fa0ecbff40cfba6856177024da05,
title = "Less is more: lemurs (Eulemur spp.) may benefit from loss of trichromatic vision",
abstract = "Abstract: Vertebrate color vision is an ideal system for studying the gains and losses of genetic variation across lineages and impacts on behavior. Among placental mammals, trichromatic vision is unique to primates and is argued to be adaptive for foraging on reddish food. However, trichromacy is variably present in lemurs, including species within the cathemeral genus Eulemur, due to inter- and intra-specific variation in X-linked opsin genes. Although this variation could result from genetic drift, it could also reflect ecological adaptation. To understand ecological contributions to color vision variation, we examined cone opsin genes of 11 Eulemur species. We found that only E. flavifrons and E. macaco have polymorphic trichromacy. Most dichromatic species have an “M” (green-shifted) opsin; uniquely, one species (E. rubriventer) has dichromacy based on an “L” (red-shifted) opsin. This latter result appears to represent loss of polymorphic trichromacy from a dichromatic (M opsin) or polymorphic Eulemur ancestor. To address potential ecological explanations for opsin variation, we studied the dietary behavior of wild E. rubriventer and collected reflectance spectra from plant species consumed. Visual models suggest that trichromacy should provide an advantage for detecting reddish foods; however, luminance contrasts were greatest for dichromats with the L opsin. As E. rubriventer are often active in low-light rainforest conditions, luminance cues may be relatively important, which could favor the L opsin, while also leading to relaxed selection on, or selection against, trichromacy. The presence of different opsin alleles across Eulemur species could represent adaptations related to diet, activity pattern, or habitat. Significance statement: Loss of genetic variation, often thought to be maladaptive, can occur through natural selection. Among primates, some species have trichromatic color vision, the ability to distinguish reddish and greenish hues; others are red-green colorblind (dichromatic). We examined adaptive explanations for color vision differences by studying cone opsin genes and behavior in wild lemurs (Eulemur)—a genus that is active both day and night. We found that color vision is variable in Eulemur species, and full trichromatic vision was likely lost in at least one lineage. Foraging ecology of dichromatic Eulemur rubriventer indicates that trichromatic vision should be advantageous for foraging on reddish foods, but brightness cues are more salient to this species’ vision. We suggest brightness may be more important than color to this species, particularly at night, and loss of trichromacy could be adaptive in some lemurs.",
author = "Jacobs, {Rachel L.} and Veilleux, {Carrie C.} and Louis, {Edward E.} and Herrera, {James P.} and Chihiro Hiramatsu and Frankel, {David C.} and Irwin, {Mitchell T.} and Melin, {Amanda D.} and Bradley, {Brenda J.}",
year = "2019",
month = "2",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s00265-018-2629-9",
language = "English",
volume = "73",
journal = "Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology",
issn = "0340-5443",
publisher = "Springer Verlag",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Less is more

T2 - lemurs (Eulemur spp.) may benefit from loss of trichromatic vision

AU - Jacobs, Rachel L.

AU - Veilleux, Carrie C.

AU - Louis, Edward E.

AU - Herrera, James P.

AU - Hiramatsu, Chihiro

AU - Frankel, David C.

AU - Irwin, Mitchell T.

AU - Melin, Amanda D.

AU - Bradley, Brenda J.

PY - 2019/2/1

Y1 - 2019/2/1

N2 - Abstract: Vertebrate color vision is an ideal system for studying the gains and losses of genetic variation across lineages and impacts on behavior. Among placental mammals, trichromatic vision is unique to primates and is argued to be adaptive for foraging on reddish food. However, trichromacy is variably present in lemurs, including species within the cathemeral genus Eulemur, due to inter- and intra-specific variation in X-linked opsin genes. Although this variation could result from genetic drift, it could also reflect ecological adaptation. To understand ecological contributions to color vision variation, we examined cone opsin genes of 11 Eulemur species. We found that only E. flavifrons and E. macaco have polymorphic trichromacy. Most dichromatic species have an “M” (green-shifted) opsin; uniquely, one species (E. rubriventer) has dichromacy based on an “L” (red-shifted) opsin. This latter result appears to represent loss of polymorphic trichromacy from a dichromatic (M opsin) or polymorphic Eulemur ancestor. To address potential ecological explanations for opsin variation, we studied the dietary behavior of wild E. rubriventer and collected reflectance spectra from plant species consumed. Visual models suggest that trichromacy should provide an advantage for detecting reddish foods; however, luminance contrasts were greatest for dichromats with the L opsin. As E. rubriventer are often active in low-light rainforest conditions, luminance cues may be relatively important, which could favor the L opsin, while also leading to relaxed selection on, or selection against, trichromacy. The presence of different opsin alleles across Eulemur species could represent adaptations related to diet, activity pattern, or habitat. Significance statement: Loss of genetic variation, often thought to be maladaptive, can occur through natural selection. Among primates, some species have trichromatic color vision, the ability to distinguish reddish and greenish hues; others are red-green colorblind (dichromatic). We examined adaptive explanations for color vision differences by studying cone opsin genes and behavior in wild lemurs (Eulemur)—a genus that is active both day and night. We found that color vision is variable in Eulemur species, and full trichromatic vision was likely lost in at least one lineage. Foraging ecology of dichromatic Eulemur rubriventer indicates that trichromatic vision should be advantageous for foraging on reddish foods, but brightness cues are more salient to this species’ vision. We suggest brightness may be more important than color to this species, particularly at night, and loss of trichromacy could be adaptive in some lemurs.

AB - Abstract: Vertebrate color vision is an ideal system for studying the gains and losses of genetic variation across lineages and impacts on behavior. Among placental mammals, trichromatic vision is unique to primates and is argued to be adaptive for foraging on reddish food. However, trichromacy is variably present in lemurs, including species within the cathemeral genus Eulemur, due to inter- and intra-specific variation in X-linked opsin genes. Although this variation could result from genetic drift, it could also reflect ecological adaptation. To understand ecological contributions to color vision variation, we examined cone opsin genes of 11 Eulemur species. We found that only E. flavifrons and E. macaco have polymorphic trichromacy. Most dichromatic species have an “M” (green-shifted) opsin; uniquely, one species (E. rubriventer) has dichromacy based on an “L” (red-shifted) opsin. This latter result appears to represent loss of polymorphic trichromacy from a dichromatic (M opsin) or polymorphic Eulemur ancestor. To address potential ecological explanations for opsin variation, we studied the dietary behavior of wild E. rubriventer and collected reflectance spectra from plant species consumed. Visual models suggest that trichromacy should provide an advantage for detecting reddish foods; however, luminance contrasts were greatest for dichromats with the L opsin. As E. rubriventer are often active in low-light rainforest conditions, luminance cues may be relatively important, which could favor the L opsin, while also leading to relaxed selection on, or selection against, trichromacy. The presence of different opsin alleles across Eulemur species could represent adaptations related to diet, activity pattern, or habitat. Significance statement: Loss of genetic variation, often thought to be maladaptive, can occur through natural selection. Among primates, some species have trichromatic color vision, the ability to distinguish reddish and greenish hues; others are red-green colorblind (dichromatic). We examined adaptive explanations for color vision differences by studying cone opsin genes and behavior in wild lemurs (Eulemur)—a genus that is active both day and night. We found that color vision is variable in Eulemur species, and full trichromatic vision was likely lost in at least one lineage. Foraging ecology of dichromatic Eulemur rubriventer indicates that trichromatic vision should be advantageous for foraging on reddish foods, but brightness cues are more salient to this species’ vision. We suggest brightness may be more important than color to this species, particularly at night, and loss of trichromacy could be adaptive in some lemurs.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85060608691&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85060608691&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s00265-018-2629-9

DO - 10.1007/s00265-018-2629-9

M3 - Article

VL - 73

JO - Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology

JF - Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology

SN - 0340-5443

IS - 2

M1 - 22

ER -